Marketing Consultant
Product Manager jobs
Hiring the right product manager is one of the most important decisions a company can make. A skilled product manager (PM) drives product vision, aligns cross-functional teams and ensures the delivery of solutions that meet both user needs and business goals. But hiring mistakes happen and the cost of a poor hire in a PM role can be high and result in delayed projects, misaligned priorities and missed market opportunities.
To help you avoid costly mistakes when recruiting, this blog explores common red flags to watch for when interviewing product manager candidates. By identifying these warning signs early, hiring managers can make more informed decisions and build stronger product teams.
It is worth noting, this guidance is general based on our experience from the past 24 years as specialist recruiters for product manager jobs and should be adapted based on the seniority of the product manager job you’re hiring for. Interview questions and red flags may differ between junior and senior roles.
Other useful resources
75 best product management interview questions
The cost of a bad hire in product management
Three core jobs of a product manager
1. Lack of clear product thinking in product manager jobs candidates
One of the foundational skills required for product manager jobs is strong product thinking, the ability to understand customer problems deeply and translate them into compelling product strategies and roadmaps. During interviews, candidates should demonstrate a clear vision of how they approach building products.
Red flags to watch for:
- Struggling to articulate a coherent product vision or strategy.
- Focusing on feature lists rather than the underlying user needs or business outcomes.
- Providing vague or generic answers when asked to describe how they would improve a product.
How to probe:
Ask open-ended questions such as:
- “Can you describe a product you’ve managed and how you decided what to build next?”
- “How do you identify and prioritise user problems?”
Look for candidates who focus on impact, clearly connect features to user pain points, and demonstrate a user-first mindset.
2. Poor cross-functional communication skills in product manager jobs candidates
Product managers are the linchpins of product teams, bridging engineering, design, marketing and other stakeholders. Effective communication is critical to ensure alignment and collaboration.
Red flags to watch for:
- Difficulty explaining complex ideas in simple terms.
- Talking over interviewers or failing to listen actively.
- Ignoring or dismissing other team members’ input in past experiences.
- Providing answers that suggest siloed working rather than collaboration.
How to assess:
Use behavioural interview questions like:
- “Tell me about a time when you had to influence a team without formal authority.”
- “Describe a situation where you had to resolve conflict between stakeholders.”
Candidates who provide clear examples of empathy, persuasion, and negotiation are likely better communicators.
3. Inability to prioritise effectively - a red flag in product manager jobs candidates
Prioritisation is arguably one of the toughest but most essential skills required in product manager jobs. Every product decision involves trade-offs, and a great PM knows how to focus on what drives the most value.
Red flags to watch for:
- Candidates unable to clearly justify how they prioritise features or tasks.
- Relying on gut feeling without considering data or stakeholder input.
- Avoiding tough trade-offs or deferring prioritisation decisions to others.
How to test:
Give candidates a prioritisation exercise during the interview:
- Present a hypothetical backlog and ask them to prioritise the features, explaining their rationale.
Look for structured thinking frameworks such as RICE (Reach, Impact, Confidence, Effort) or MoSCoW (Must-have, Should-have, Could-have, Won’t-have).
4. Lack of data-driven decision making
Data is the lifeblood of modern product manager jobs. PMs need to measure success, analyse user behaviour, and make decisions based on evidence rather than assumptions.
Red flags to watch for:
- Ignoring or downplaying the role of data in product decisions.
- Inability to articulate relevant metrics (KPIs) for their products.
- Making decisions purely based on intuition or anecdotal evidence.
How to evaluate:
Ask questions such as:
- “What metrics do you track to measure product success?”
- “Describe a time when data changed your product decision.”
Look for candidates who demonstrate comfort with analytics tools, A/B testing, and iterating based on data insights.
5. Overemphasis on technical skills (or lack thereof) in candidates
While candidates don’t need to write code, understanding technical constraints and possibilities is important, especially when working closely with engineers.
Red flags to watch for:
- Candidates who either focus too much on technical details at the expense of business and user needs.
- Or, those who show no technical awareness, making unrealistic demands or ignoring feasibility.
- Overly defensive or dismissive when technical challenges are discussed.
How to balance:
Look for candidates who can comfortably discuss technical concepts without dominating conversations or losing sight of user value. Ask questions like:
- “How do you work with engineering teams to balance technical debt and feature development?”
This will reveal their ability to collaborate effectively with developers
6. Inflexibility or resistance to feedback
The product development process is iterative. PMs hired for product manager jobs must be adaptable, open to feedback and willing to pivot when new information emerges.
Red flags to watch for:
- Defensiveness or unwillingness to discuss failures or mistakes.
- Rigid answers suggesting a “my way or the highway” mindset.
- Lack of examples showing learning from feedback or course corrections.
How to identify:
Use behavioural questions such as:
- “Tell me about a time you received critical feedback. How did you respond?”
- “Describe a situation where you had to change your product strategy based on new insights.”
Candidates who show humility and growth mindset are more likely to succeed.
7. Lack of passion for the product or industry
This might sound like an obvious one, but product managers need to be genuinely engaged and passionate about their products and industries. This enthusiasm drives creativity, resilience and ownership.
Red flags to watch for:
- Vague or generic responses when asked why they want the job or why they care about the product.
- Seeming uninterested or unprepared during the interview.
- Lack of questions about the company’s product, market, or users.
How to gauge passion:
Ask:
- “What excites you about this product or industry?”
- “How do you stay informed about market trends?”
Engaged candidates often come prepared with research and thoughtful questions.
Conclusion
Filling product manager roles with the right talent is critical to your company’s success. Spotting red flags during interviews can save time, money and frustration down the road. By watching for poor product thinking, weak communication, prioritisation struggles, lack of data-driven decision making, imbalanced technical focus, resistance to feedback and low passion, you’ll be better equipped to make smart hiring decisions.
Invest the time in structured interviews, practical exercises, and multiple assessment methods to find the candidate who not only has the right skills but also fits your company culture and product vision.
If you’re looking for expert help sourcing and assessing top candidates for senior product management roles, reach out to our recruitment team today.
Browse our live roles, or get in touch if you’re ready to hire.
Our management team
We understand how critical key senior product manager recruitment projects are for our customers’ staffing needs. Therefore, all of our PM search assignments are led or overseen by one of our management team, with support from our experienced search consultants and researchers, who will often have an industry specialism.
Read about our management team or speak confidentially to one of our founding directors.
